Personality and Psychopathology: Research Annual Report 2003
Section Head: Dr. R. Michael Bagby
Research in the Personality and Psychopathology Research Section examines a broad range of themes related to personality and
psychopathology. We also develop tests and instruments to assess personality and related constructs, and develop strategies
to assess and treat mental disorders using the Internet.
Our current projects explore: alternative structures of personality psychopathology; the effects of personality traits in
treatment outcomes for disorders such as depression, anxiety and problem gambling; the influence of personality on the development
of mental disorders; the influence of acute distress on personality and its assessment; and the role of neurotransmitter mechanisms
in personality.
Personality and Cognitive Vulnerability and Problem Gambling
Surprisingly little is known about the personality and cognitive characteristics of people with gambling problems. Drs. R.
Michael Bagby and Peter Farvolden are attempting to identify personality and cognitive factors that distinguish people who
remain "social gamblers" from those whose gambling activities escalate into a dysfunction or problem gambling.
Results to date suggest that, in contrast to people with gambling problems who seek treatment, people with gambling problems
who do not seek treatment and social gamblers are not characterized by high levels of psychopathology or alterations in cognitive
functioning. This finding challenges conventional thinking about problem gambling.
Behavioural Inhibition, Behavioural Activation, Personality and Novelty
Based mainly on research on how animals learn, Gray's influential motivational model (1994) proposes biological systems that
mediate all of our different motivations and emotions: the behavioural inhibition system (BIS), the behavioural activation
system (BAS) and the flight-fight system. Gray's BIS and BAS offer promise for explaining a variety of normal and psychopathological
behaviour.
We are developing novel paradigms to study the relations between BIS and BAS sensitivity, other systems of personality and
preference for novelty. We are tentatively exploring connections to psychopathology by examining these relationships in different
patient groups.
Panic Disorder, Agoraphobia, Anxiety Sensitivity and Attachment
According to current explanations of panic disorder and agoraphobia (PD/AG), panic attacks are the result of a "false alarm"
combined with an over-attentiveness to internal bodily sensations and/or a tendency to catastrophize. Although there is considerable
support for the current explanations of PD/AG there is also some evidence that increased vulnerability to separation distress
and/or an "insecure" attachment style may also have an important role in PD/AG.
Results to date suggest that neuroticism and attachment style predict anxiety sensitivity, which in turn predicts severity
and intensity of panic symptoms. These results suggest some benefit from using personality and attachment dimensions to better
understand the onset and maintenance of PD/AG.
Personality, Positive Mood and Attentional Biases in Depression
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is an extremely prevalent mental health problem with vast socio-emotional and economic costs.
A continuing challenge in the treatment of MDD is the high rates of relapse and recurrence.
This project examines the potential role of "positive" traits such as behavioural activation sensitivity, extraversion, ability
to experience positive mood and "positive" cognitive biases in predicting response to treatment and relapse in depression.
Results to date suggest that response to a positive mood induction may help predict treatment response.
Internet Assessment and Treatment
Considerable data suggest that the Internet can be a powerful tool for delivering collaborative assessment and treatment.
We have recently presented data supporting the potential utility of a Web-based tool for assessing depression and anxiety
disorders in primary care. In addition, we have presented data supporting the reach, patterns of use and potential efficacy
of a free Web-based smoking cessation program.
Application of the Five-Factor Model of Personality to Psychopathology
Recognition of the limitations associated with the categorical approach to personality psychopathology has led to the development
of several new dimensional models of personality psychopathology.
Our ongoing research attempts to find if the dimensions of personality represented by the Five-Factor Model of Personality
can be applied successfully to a variety of patient samples and used to better understand the relevant neurobiology, psycho-pharmacology
and structure of personality psychopathology.
Personality, Limbic-Cortical Function and Vulnerability to Major Depression and Other Imaging Studies
This project attempts to unify two parallel lines of research examining vulnerability to depression. One line shows that pet
scans in patients with depression display specific patterns to induced sad mood; the other shows that individuals who have
a high score on "neuroticism" are vulnerable to develop depression.
Our research examines whether never-depressed "normal" subjects with high neuroticism scores show the same response as people
who are depressed or were previously depressed. These results have recently been published in Neuroimage.
Personality as a Mediator of Treatment Outcome
This ongoing project, now in its third year, examines whether different types of personality traits (dependency and self-criticism)
moderate and/or mediate treatment outcome differently in three standard and empirically established effective interventions
for depression (interpersonal therapy, cognitive-behavioural therapy and pharmacotherapy). Previous studies have shown that
all these treatments are about equally effective, but no study has systematically examined whether targeting depressive symptoms
related to personality traits mediates outcome differently.
Personality, Life Stress and Recurrent Major Depression
More than half of all people with major depression will have multiple recurrent episodes throughout their lives; the impact
is often devastating. Recurrence of depression is also an ongoing burden on the public health system. For these reasons, we
are trying to understand the mechanism that perpetuates the recurrence of depression.
Several risk factors for recurrent depression include childhood adversity, personality style and poor social support. But
what is the mechanism that underlies the relationship between these risk factors and recurrence?
In collaboration with Dr. Kate Harkness (Queen's University), Dr. Bagby is conducting research to see if people who have both
depression and a history of childhood adversity, disrupted personality and poor interpersonal functioning are generating stressful
events that precipitate new episodes of depression. If this is found to be true, treatments that target stress generation
may ultimately help prevent depression from becoming a lifelong disorder.
Drs. Harkness and Bagby have recently received an operating grant from the Ontario Mental Health Foundation to examine this
causal model of depression recurrence, with clear targets for treatment and prevention.