Recognizing Depression
Hear Me
I think a lot of girls don't know . . . the signs of depression. I didn't know I was depressed until, like, years after.
[Depression is] being unable to actually experience happiness for a long period of time. No matter how hard you try, you're
always wondering whether or not it's your ‘period' of Lord knows what.
I had been experiencing postpartum blues after weaning my toddler. I wondered why I felt the way I did. I was lonely, sad,
angry and just not happy . . . I was hiding inside; I did not want others to know what I really felt. This took so much energy
out of me; I made myself physically ill.
You're just so used to, like, having all these downfalls and just being kicked when you're down. After a while, you just have
no hope anymore. You're just: "Well, this is the way it is!" and you just try and just accept it and live with the fact that,
"Hey, my life sucks and it's always gonna suck." That's not a good state of mind to be in . . . And it's really hard to keep
an optimistic side . . . there's nobody really there to help you out. For so many years now, people have been trying to help
me and I never really saw it . . . I didn't really think that they could have helped me, but I'm wishing now that maybe I
should have taken that help a long time ago. Maybe things wouldn't have reached the point that they have today.
I think many young black women who are depressed get stereotyped as angry, aggressive and violent. If a physician does not
fully understand how culture and race play a role in how you express yourself and your feelings, illnesses such as depression
may be undermined or overlooked. It is very difficult for black females to find physicians who can relate to them.
A western doctor takes the visual signs of his patients seriously. If they have a broken arm, he acknowledges their pain.
If they have fever, then he looks for other symptoms and makes a diagnosis and treats the problem. When I came into my doctor's
office, I gave him my symptoms. They were not taken seriously because they were not physical.
I think a lot of girls don't know . . . the signs of depression. I didn't know I was depressed until, like, years after. .
. . And it was clinical depression too. . . . I said to myself "No! Maybe I'm just sad today."
Understand Me
Family and friends may tell a young woman that there is nothing to be depressed about because "you have so much going for
you" or "you are so pretty and smart." Given the stigma associated with being a teenager (some people talk about teenagers
as "lazy," "unmotivated" and "angry") you might hear someone say, "They're not depressed. It's just typical adolescent behaviour."
Others may not take a young woman's feelings seriously. Even professionals may have difficulty making a differential diagnosis
between clinical depression and adolescent development and identity issues. Doctors, parents and others may dismiss depressive
symptoms as simply a phase or a normal part of adolescence. This lack of understanding about depression in young women impedes
their ability to reach out for help.
The young women involved in the VALIDITY project tended not to share a mutual definition of depression. The fact that depression
takes different forms and exists to different degrees makes it harder to recognize. Some young women may express depression
through their behaviour (escaping into substance use, unsafe sex or other high-risk behaviours; difficulty engaging with others;
self-harming/cutting; difficulty concentrating); some may experience it as sadness, anxiety and being overwhelmed; and some
may experience it as aggressive behaviour and anger. They may associate their low mood with circumstances in their lives,
and blame themselves, believing they are ugly, fat, unpopular, unlovable, etc., without seeing that they are depressed. Depression
can be particularly hard to recognize when women hide their feelings, such that "typical" signs of depression may not be apparent.
There is also a need to recognize that depression is a medical illness, and is often genetically transmitted within families.
One young woman noted that sometimes depression isn't caused by external factors. A chemical imbalance may be at work and
sometimes no amount of counselling can cure the illness. As the young woman said,
You could have grown up with a perfect childhood, a perfect family and everything else, and you still have a perfect life
going for you. You're dating the best looking guy on the soccer team. . . . You're like the top GPA . . . and everything else
of that nature, but it's just simply, there's something wrong chemically with you. Like there's not enough of the happy stuff!
The prevalence of depression is higher for young women, but depression is not a normal part of adolescence. Depression may
result from an event, such as the death of someone they loved; a past trauma or abuse; a series of small stressors; or it
may be inherited genetically. Young women feel that there needs to be more information about how to identify depression, how
to understand external and internal contributing factors, and how to treat it.
Support Me
Learn as much as you can about depression. It may be hard for young women to know what depression is. There is the stereotype
of the depressed person as always crying, unable to get out of bed, suicidal. If someone doesn't have these symptoms, they
may assume that they simply can't be depressed, so it is important to find out basic information about depression.
Encourage young women to talk about their thoughts and feelings, including anger. Create an environment where they feel safe
to express their emotions - even anger - and where questions are welcomed. If there is a history of depression within a young
woman's family, it is important to discuss the potential for her to experience depression. Don't be afraid to ask for help
from other service providers. Refer to the resources section of this guide to learn more about the help that is available.
Early intervention is invaluable for recovery from depression.
There are web sites that offer information for young people who are experiencing depression or who want to research health
issues in general:
Black Women and Mental Health
http://www.blackwomenshealth.com/
This web page includes discussions about the rates of depression among African American women, factors that contribute to
depression in black women, attitudes toward mental health, recognizing depression, stigma, black women and the mental health
profession, diagnoses of mental health problems in black women, the study of the psychological functioning of black people,
prevention, and suggestions for support and recovery.
Center for Young Women's Health, Children's Hospital Boston
http://www.youngwomenshealth.org
Designed to educate and empower girls and young women aged 12 to 22, this web site provides a variety of information and services
including Teen Talk, a newsletter by teens for teens, and live on-line chats moderated by experts from the hospital and intended
as a safe place for young women to ask questions and discuss concerns about important health issues.
Families for Depression Awareness
http://www.familyaware.org/resources/options.asp
This organization provides insight about how people often lack information and support on how to help a family member or friend
who is depressed: "Clinicians focus on the depressed patient, not family and friends. In the past and even now, families are
often blamed for causing the depression. Social stigma associated with depression causes many families to live in secrecy,
afraid and unprepared to talk about the condition openly." Families that discuss depression and increase their understanding
of the condition achieve long-term positive change in family functioning and increased resiliency in children.
Teen Depression web site
http://www.teen-depression.info/index.php3
This web site offers information on prevention, detection and treatment of teen depression. It also includes statistics and
links to other resources on teen depression.
The following resources explore the importance of family, friends, teachers and others in supporting a person who is experiencing
depression:
Educating Students about Substance Use and Mental Health
http://www.camh.net/education/curriculum
A web-based curriculum resource, with ready-to-use lessons, for teachers of grades 1 to 12. See A Critical Link - Web-Based Resources for more information.
Empfield, M. & Bakalar, N. (2001). Understanding Teenage Depression: A Guide to Diagnosis, Treatment, and Management. New York: Henry Holt and Company.
Fassler, D.G. & Dumas, L.S. (1997). "Help Me, I'm Sad": Recognizing, Treating and Preventing Childhood and Adolescent Depression. New York: Penguin Group.
Graham, P. & Hughes, C. (1995). So Young, So Sad, So Listen. London: Gaskell/West London Health Promotion Agency.
A book about depression in children and adolescents during school years aimed at helping parents, teachers and teenagers to
recognize and understand depression.
Health Canada. (1999). All Together Now: How Families Are Affected by Depression and Manic Depression. Ottawa: Author.
Koplewicz, H.S. (2002). More than Moody: Recognizing and Treating Adolescent Depression. New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons.
Mondimore, F.M. (2002). Adolescent Depression: A Guide for Parents. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
National Alliance for the Mentally Ill (NAMI)
http://www.namiontario.ca
NAMI is a non-profit, grassroots, self-help, support and advocacy organization of consumers, families and friends of people
with severe mental illnesses, such as schizophrenia, major depression, bipolar disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder and
anxiety disorders. The NAMI Family-to-Family Education Program consists of a free course of 12 classes for the family members
of people who have mental illnesses.
Young Minds. Why Do Young Minds Matter? London, UK: Author.
For parents, this leaflet talks about mental health problems in young people, the things that can go wrong and the problems
this can cause. It also offers advice on the range of services that can help.
Young Minds
102-108 Clerkenwell Road, London, U.K. EC1M 5SA
Tel.: 020 7336 8445 (from the U.K.)