An Integrated Biopsychosocial Perspective
Excerpted from Chapter One: Theories of Addiction and Implications for Counselling in Alcohol & Drug Problems: A Practical
Guide For Counsellors
Figure 1-1 (PDF) attempts to capture the many factors that influence substance use and to show how they interact. The model was developed
for the World Health Organization (WHO, 1981). It identifies biological, personal and social factors and learning experiences, and shows how they may have
immediate or more distant influences on a person’s disposition to use drugs. It also shows that social and individual factors
can be influenced by the consequences of drug use. Other feedback mechanisms that can have positive or negative influences
on future use, depending on individual users and their circumstances, are also identified.
The model shows that drug actions and their effects may lead to biological responses that account for tolerance and drug-specific
withdrawal symptoms. These responses may have either adverse or reinforcing properties. While withdrawal symptoms may initially
be aversive, they can be relieved by taking more drugs, and this strengthens the drug-taking response. Repeated experiences
of withdrawal can activate a classical conditioning process whereby previously neutral stimuli elicit withdrawal symptoms,
or drug-like effects, and lead to further drug use. Over time, through a process of generalization, a variety of internal
and external cues (e.g., anxiety, stress or social events) may be associated with withdrawal symptoms and drug effects. This
process can lead to an extreme narrowing of a person’s repertoire of responses to cues, and a tendency to use drugs whenever
these cues are present. The person often increases his or her involvement with other drug users, who facilitate access to
drugs and otherwise support drug use. Conversely, involvements with people who might encourage reduced drug use and associated
behaviours may become less frequent and significant.
Some Implications for Counselling
The model shown in Figure 1-1 (PDF) suggests that drug taking can be reduced by making the experience less rewarding and making abstinence or reduced use more
rewarding. This could be achieved through a variety of biological, psychological and environmental interventions, some of
which have been mentioned in this chapter. A useful summary of the objectives of such interventions was proposed by Daley
and Marlatt (1992). These objectives are indicated in Table 1-1 together with the relevant clinical aids or procedures that
have the strongest empirical support.
Other chapters in this book describe many of the specific practices identified in Table 1-1. Further evidence for their effectiveness
can be found in recent reports from Health Canada (1999, 2000, 2001a, 2001b & 2002), on the Treatment Improvement Protocols
(TIPs) Web site ( www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/bv.fcgi?rid=hstat5.part.22441 ) maintained by the U.S. Center for Substance Abuse Treatment, and on the Web site of the U.S. National Institute on Drug Abuse
(NIDA; www.nida.nih.gov/). However, more research is needed to determine the effectiveness of different treatments for different types of clients,
especially for women and youth.
Figure 1-1 Factors Affecting Drug Use and Abuse (PDF version only)
Table 1-1 Objectives, Treatment Components and Empirically Supported Clinical Aids
|
Treatment Objectives
|
Empirically Supported Aids / Procedures
|
|
Help client identify high-risk situations and develop strategies to deal with them
|
Assessments using inventories of risk situations Behavioural rehearsal Covert modelling Assertiveness training Coping imagery Reframing reactions to relapse Mediation and relaxation Exercise
|
|
Help client understand relapse as a process and as an event
|
Methods to help client identify factors that contribute to relapse (e.g., functional analysis or instruments such as the Inventory
of Drug Taking Situations [IDTS], which helps clients identify high-risk situations for relapse
|
|
Help client understand and deal with substance cues and cravings
|
Monitor cravings Behavioural interventions such as avoiding, leaving or changing situations that trigger or worsen cravings; and redirecting
activities or getting involved in pleasant activities Help and support from others Self-help meeting to learn how others have coped Medication such as naltrexone (ReVia®) or disulfiram (Antabuse®)
|
|
Help client understand and deal with social pressure to use substances
|
Identify high-risk relationships Assess effects of thoughts, feelings and behaviours Plan and practise alternative coping skills using role playing Evaluate results and modify the coping strategy if required
|
|
Help client develop and enhance a supportive social network
|
Involve family and significant others Refer to self-help groups Help client decide who should be included in or excluded from social network Rehearse asking for help/support Develop a written action plan
|
|
Help client develop ways of coping with negative emotional states
|
Various methods depending on the sources manifestations and consequences of client's emotional state. may include:
-
treatment for mental health problems
-
anger management
-
leisure planning (for boredom)
-
counselling on attitudes and beliefs
|
|
Assess client for psychiatric disorders and facilitate treatment
|
Monitor target moods
Participate in pleasant activities
Develop routines and structures for daily living
Identify signs of relapse
Psychotherapy
Pharmacology
|
|
Facilitate transition to follow-up outpatient care or aftercare (for residential programs)
|
Motivational therapy prior to discharge Telephone or mail reminders for initial appointments Reinforcers for participation in aftercare (e.g. , coupons, certificates)
|
|
Help client learn to cope with cognitive distortions ("stinking thinking")
|
Use workshops to list faulty beliefs such as "awfulizing," over-generalizing, selective abstraction and jumping to conclusions Help show what is wrong with these beliefs Help develop new beliefs
|
|
Help client develop a more balanced lifestyle
|
All of the above Identify sources of stress and pleasure / self-fulfillment Develop and implement plans to avoid or deal with stress, and to do more fulfilling things
|
|
Facilitate pharmacological interventions as an adjunct to psychosocial treatment
|
Naloxone as an adjunct to psychosocial treatments Medication for psychiatric disorders Methadone for opioid addiction
|
|
Help client develop plans to manage a lapse or relapse
|
Self-talk or behavioural procedures Talk to family Go to self-help group Seek professional help Carry a list of names and phone numbers of people who can help Carry a reminder card about what to do in the case of a lapse Learn from the experience
|

Alcohol and Drug Problems: A Practical Guide For Counsellors